Evaluation of Student's Creative Writing Assignment

Evaluation Criteria

1. Creativity (60%)
2. Structure (20%)
3. Language (20%)

Overall Mark: 73% (C)

---

Detailed Evaluation

1. Creativity (60%)

• Strengths:

  • The piece presents a vivid dystopian world with intriguing imagery. The contrast between Emila’s innocent perspective and the bleak realities of her environment is compelling.
  • The introduction of a companion animal adds emotional depth to the narrative.

• Areas for Improvement:

  • The storyline could benefit from additional conflict or development. For instance, exploring Emila's feelings about her circumstances could enhance engagement.
  • The conclusion could be expanded to provide more resolution or insight into Emila’s future.

Score: 36/60

---

2. Structure (20%)

• Strengths:

  • The story has a clear beginning, middle, and end, maintaining a logical flow.

• Areas for Improvement:

  • Paragraphs could be better defined. More use of paragraph breaks would help distinguish different ideas and enhance readability.
  • The pacing is uneven; some sections linger too long while others rush through important details. A more balanced approach would improve the overall structure.

Score: 12/20

---

3. Language (20%)

• Strengths:

  • Descriptive language enriches the narrative, making the scene come alive for the reader.
  • Some phrases, such as “the effect of WW3” and “a living hell,” are impactful and evoke strong imagery.

• Areas for Improvement:

  • There are several grammatical errors, such as “emila” which should be “Emila” and missing commas in compound sentences.
  • The phrase “searched for any signs of life” could be simplified to "looked for signs of life" for clarity.
  • Inconsistent tense usage should be corrected for consistency throughout the narrative.

Score: 12/20

---

Tips for Improvement

1. Expand Storytelling Elements:

   • Dive deeper into character emotions and motivations to create a stronger connection with the reader.

2. Enhance Structure:

   • Use paragraph breaks strategically to separate different ideas and make the text easier to read.

3. Grammar and Punctuation:

   • Review grammar rules, especially concerning capitalisation and punctuation to improve readability.
   • Incorporate varied sentence structures to enhance writing style.

4. Check for Consistency:

   • Ensure that tenses remain consistent throughout the narrative to avoid confusion.

5. Explore Various Perspectives:

   • Consider writing from different character viewpoints or delving into their backgrounds to enrich the story.

6. Practice Extensive Reading:

   • Reading a variety of genres can help you develop a better understanding of different writing styles and techniques.

7. Seek Feedback:

   • Don’t hesitate to share your work with peers or teachers for insights that can enhance your writing.

8. Work on Vocabulary:

   • Incorporate synonyms and varied word choices to avoid repetition and make your writing more engaging.

Conclusion

This creative writing assignment contains many vivid descriptions and ideas but requires additional attention to detail and structure. By focusing on the outlined areas for improvement, you can enhance your writing skills and create even more engaging narratives in the future. Well done on your efforts!