aidemia--modules-lessonstartideas_type	Give a creative idea how to begin a lesson
Which subject	Phylosophy
What age group	College
What topic	free will
Quantity	1
Any other preferences

Engaging the Mind: The Paradox of Free Will

Introduction

Welcome, scholars, to today’s exploration of one of philosophy's most profound and perplexing subjects: free will. As we dive deeper into this age-old debate, I invite you to consider the implications, responsibilities, and questions that arise from our understanding of whether we truly have control over our actions.

The Icebreaker: A Thought Experiment

To ignite our discussions, let’s start with a thought experiment—an innovative way to engage your minds and challenge your assumptions about free will.

Scenario: The Choice Machine

Imagine you are presented with a cutting-edge device known as the Choice Machine. This device analyzes every decision you make and presents you with the optimal choice based on your desires, values, and long-term goals. For example:

• If you are deciding what career to pursue, the Choice Machine will inform you of the path that aligns perfectly with your passions and strengths.
• Faced with a moral dilemma, it will present the ethically superior option based on universal principles.

However, here’s the twist: every time you use the Choice Machine, the choices become less about your authentic intentions and more about what the machine deems best for you.

Questions for Reflection

1. Would you trust the Choice Machine? Why or why not?
2. How does the intervention of the Choice Machine affect your sense of free will?
3. If it leads you to a "better" life, does that justify diminishing your role in making decisions?

Group Discussion

In breakout groups of four to five, discuss your thoughts on the Choice Machine. Consider the philosophical implications:

• What does this scenario suggest about autonomy?
• Are there situations in real life where we encounter our own "Choice Machines" (e.g., societal expectations, technology, etc.)?
• What is the relationship between determinism and free will illustrated by this thought experiment?

Conclusion

After your discussions, we will reconvene to share insights and reflect on how this exercise has shaped your understanding of free will. As we continue our journey through philosophical texts and theories today, keep the questions raised by the Choice Machine at the forefront of your mind.

Let’s get started on this intellectual adventure!