The essay is generally well-written with only a few minor errors. For instance, "this trut" at the end is a typographical error that should be corrected to "truth." There are occasional run-on sentences, such as, "The impact of nature can be both beneficial and detrimental to one’s state of mind, and the effects of this in Shelley are exposed as she imagines such a dark, gory, and drastic story as Frankenstein." This sentence could be divided for clarity.
Score: 8/10
The essay correctly references Mary Shelley’s summer in 1816 with Lord Byron in Switzerland. However, the claim about volcanic dust affecting the weather should be more specific; it is widely understood that the eruption of Mount Tambora in 1815 caused significant climatic changes, leading to the "Year Without a Summer" in 1816. The provided page number citations are unverified; students should ideally cross-check references against a reliable edition of the text.
Score: 7/10
The writing style is sophisticated, appropriate for a college-level paper. The author conveys complex ideas about Romanticism and the connection between Mary Shelley's life and Frankenstein effectively. However, further elaboration on certain arguments would improve coherence. For example, the transition between discussing the external conditions affecting Mary and Victor could be smoother.
Score: 8/10
There are appropriate citations for both Mary Shelley and Percy Bysshe Shelley, which contribute to academic integrity. However, there's a lack of a bibliography or works cited section, which is essential in academic writing. Ensuring that direct quotes from other texts are properly formatted and attributed is critical.
Score: 6/10
The essay is well-centered on the connections between Mary Shelley’s life and her novel, making insightful correlations. It thoroughly explores themes relevant to the tragedy of Victor Frankenstein and the significant influence of nature and dreams. However, it could delve deeper into specific plot points or character analyses for a more rounded discourse.
Score: 9/10
The essay demonstrates a solid understanding of Frankenstein and the influences surrounding its creation. The student has effectively linked Mary Shelley's life with the themes present in her novel. Improving factual accuracy, providing clearer transitions, and including proper citations would enhance the overall quality of the essay.